I've built a spirit grammer to process the token sequence of wave.

1. Scope missing in macros.

The first problem arose when I tried to write the wave token equivalent of chlit:

    struct token_lit : public boost::spirit::char_parser<token_lit>
    {
       token_lit(boost::wave::token_id id_) : id(id_) {}

        template <typename T>
       bool test(T id_) const
        {
            return BASE_TOKEN(id_) == BASE_TOKEN(id);
        }

boost::wave::token_id id;
};
The code above doesn't compile, because BASE_TOKEN uses constants from boost::wave without explicit scope. Lines to fix: token_ids.hpp(37-40,305,309).

2. Newline token reports bad position.

For debug purposes I reported the match positions in the grammer actions using the file_position interface of the wave token type. The results were quite strange, sometimes pointing into the middle of a keyword, so I decided to take a smaller step and modified the wave example (the one in the documentation) just to see what happens, as follows:

    while (first != last) {
        std::cout << "value: \"" << (*first).get_value() << "\" pos: " <<
            (*first).get_position ().get_file () << "(" << (*first).get_position ().get_line () << ") @" <<
            (*first).get_position ().get_column () << std::endl;
        ++first;
    }
Attached you can find some very small inputs and their corresponding outputs.

2.1. A file containing only whites and comments produced no tokens at all

2.2. Position of the enter token reports the new line number but the old column

2.3. The #line directive affects the position in a very strange way

Please clarify if some of these are not errors.

Oops, I almost forgot, I am using a fresh verison from the CVS repository already containing the fix for the SF bug #1274584.

Best regards,

József Mihalicza