From: Stewart, Robert (stewart_at_[hidden])
Date: 2002-02-14 13:09:44
From: John Maddock [mailto:John_Maddock_at_[hidden]]
> I'm going to go off on a slight tangent though because in
> several places we
> require ranges of strings (regex, tokeniser, and Darin Adler's string
> algorithms), there is as yet no standard way to represent them.
> regex uses something like a pair of iterators.
> tokeniser just copies the range into a std::string (but can easily be
> modified to use something else).
> DA's string algorithms use a kind of substring (but one
> that's inherently
> tied to std::basic_string).
> It seems to me that we've all been trying to avoid the issue
> as much as
> possible, so recently I've begun work on a substring class - one that
> represents any iterator range - but that "looks like" a string.
> Roughly you can do anything with a substring that you can with a const
> std::string, except call c_str() or data().
For the cases you cite, a substring of this sort may be useful. However, in
general, a const substring will provide only a portion of the value of a .
To make substrings valuable, one should be able to modify the underlying
string. I used RWCString years ago, which provided a powerful RWCSubString
class. It allowed things like the following:
RWCString foo("The red fox jumped over the lazy dog");
foo(4,3) = "quick, brown";
std::cout << foo << endl;
The result is "The quick, brown fox...." Such a facility would be highly
useful. IIRC, RWCString used COW, so RWCSubString, the return type of the
function operator, could share the underlying string for const operations
and force a non-shared copy for non-const operations. That luxury is
clearly not available for std::basic_string and presents a design challenge.
However, I would be happy to live with the potential for the substring
outliving its string; that's no different than an iterator being
invalidated. You just have to know what's valid and what's undefined
Susquehanna International Group, LLP
Boost list run by bdawes at acm.org, gregod at cs.rpi.edu, cpdaniel at pacbell.net, john at johnmaddock.co.uk