From: Douglas Gregor (gregod_at_[hidden])
Date: 2002-08-02 09:00:52
On Thursday 01 August 2002 11:37 pm, Petr Kocmid wrote:
> publicizing value enum, which is now private will allow using switch. The
> question is, if the elegant if(x)..else if(!x)..else... idiom will not be
> broken by optimization on some compilers which presume default language
> semantics ("warning: unreachable code", sounds familiar?). switch would be
> safer for compiler portability, also more readable. This if...else...else
> idiom should be definitely part of the test!
I don't mind publicizing the 'value' enum, but I can't imagine a compiler
misoptimizing if if(x)..else if (!x)..else idiom. Compilers don't do
aggressive optimizations like that around function calls (!x requires two
function calls), and after the inliner the expressions become something very
unlike x and !x. I'll add in the testcase to see if any compilers do make the
mistake, though :)
> safe_bool should assert if indeterminate?
Well, safe_bool only has 2 states, so it can't be indeterminate. If you mean
the conversion to safe_bool, then I disagree. I've found it extremely useful
to use 'if (x)' meaning 'if x is always true' in my own work, though it's
very likely that in different domains this isn't as useful.
> I'd prefer the name change to tristate_bool or multistate_bool respectively
> with namespace logic (I mean boost::logic), which certainly will please the
Does the addition of 'state' add that much to the name for the simple, 3-state
case? The name 'tribool' is so nice and short :)
As for the namespace 'logic', I think its perfectly reasonable if we expect to
see more logic libraries entering Boost. Otherwise, it seems like overkill
for such a small utility class.
> Perhaps, if tristate_bool implementation will remain with
> non-customizable indeterminate, multistate_bool could be written more
> generic way later on?
That'd be my favored path. Get us all to agree on the interface for the simple
case, then generalize.
> Maybe some type traits should be added for such a 3-state too.
> Petr Kocmid
What traits do we need?
Boost list run by bdawes at acm.org, gregod at cs.rpi.edu, cpdaniel at pacbell.net, john at johnmaddock.co.uk