From: David B. Held (dheld_at_[hidden])
Date: 2004-11-29 16:38:58
Rob Stewart wrote:
> From: Rene Rivera <grafik.list_at_[hidden]>
> -- As viewed with my browsers, which work quite nicely at other
> web sites, there is way too much white, and not enough
> black/blue from the text. IOW, the contrast is really low
> because the lines of the letters are so thin. This is more
> pronounced with the blue of the links than with the black, but
> both are a problem.
I think dense text is much harder to read. When space is at a
premium, then I think dense text is acceptable. But given the choice
between a crowded page and a more open one, I prefer the latter.
Dense text tends to make it more difficult to find things, I think.
> -- The "Participation" section should be a subsection of the
> "Welcome to Boost.org!" section. It should be a main section,
> despite how much participation is valued.
Did you mean to say "It should [not] be a main section..."? If so,
I think I agree. It's such a small paragraph that it seems a little
odd by itself.
> -- The drop down list for searching obscures the other choices.
> I think the right behavior is to search everything, or just
> the site from the home page, with an "Advanced Search" link
> that offers more search options. This helps to keep the home
> page simpler and is more in keeping with other web sites.
I guess that would be appropriate if the site were very large and
had many possible places to search. But on a site as small as Boost,
with fairly disjoint sets of data that people generally want to look
at, I think having partitioned searches is just fine.
> -- The section labeled, "About," has always mislead me. I guess
> I've been trained by Microsoft to expect application or
> organization information under that heading, so the links that
> appear in that section seem out of place. In this case,
> changing "About" to, say, "Reviews and Submissions" might be
> just the thing.
I agree that "About" is used a little unconventionally. I think
other possibilities for the section title would be "Policies",
"Protocol", "Details", "Contributing" or something along those lines.
Boost list run by bdawes at acm.org, gregod at cs.rpi.edu, cpdaniel at pacbell.net, john at johnmaddock.co.uk