Re: [boost] ScopeExit Review Begins Today

From: Jody Hagins (jody-boost-011304_at_[hidden])
Date: 2007-08-23 13:26:33

The discussion threads included comments from several people who did not
offer an actual review and/or YES/NO.  I have filtered every message
with either scope or exit in the subject, and I want to make sure I have
all the reviews.  If your name is in this list, that means I have a
YES/NO review from you.  Otherwise, I may see some discussion from you,
but no YES/NO review.

If your name is NOT in this list, but you feel you provided a review,
please point me to your review posting, or provide appropriate
clarification.  The fact that you participated in the discussion does
not mean that I know your opinion on the acceptance of ScopeExit.

In addition, I have received a few reviews via private email.  For the
sake of fairness and openness, I asked the authors to send their review
to the list.  I will not consider them unless they appear in the open
mailing list.

Thanks for your cooperation!

Kim Barrett
Aaron LaFramboise
Steven Watanabe
Ben Kuppers
Andrey Semashev
Peder Holt
Goran Mitrovic
Johan Nilsson
Pavel Vozenilek
Tom Brinkman
Maxim Yanchenko