March 2021 - Boost - lists.boost.org

C++17 and "Alice in Wonderland"
by Edward Diener 24 Mar '21

24 Mar '21

I apologize for this non-Boost related post, but I ran into what I thought was a C++17 bug in clang ( also in vc++14.2 C++17 ), whose explanation to me of why it is not a bug really sounds like the non-logic of "Alice in Wonderland". I am not putting down the person who explains to me why it is not a bug in any way, as I know he is a C++ expert, but if this is really C++17 something must be wrong with my admittedly limited understanding of C++ and where it is going. My bug report is at https://bugs.llvm.org/show_bug.cgi?id=49684 and the explanation given there just eludes me as to what C++17 is doing, as my further comments makes apparent. Does anyone actually understand how this can possibly be ? How does C++17 apparently deduce a template argument different from what the actual type is and than declare therefore a mismatch ? This is really something from another world. My apologies for bringing this up in Boost, as it is purely a C++ issue, but my original problem comes from something I have been working on in the hopes it might eventually be a Boost library, so I decided to see if any of the expert Boost contributors might know what is going on in C++17. I realize that if everyone did as I have done here the mailing list would be a mass of irrelevant posts not Boost related.

9 11

Boost 1.76 beta - linking error when including Boost
by Luigi Ballabio 24 Mar '21

24 Mar '21

Hello, I'm afraid I don't have a minimal example yet, but I thought I'd give you a heads-up in case it rings a bell. I've been trying the Boost 1.76 beta to build a library I'm maintaining. The library builds, but when I link it to an executable I'm getting an "undefined reference to `bool boost::math::isnan<long double>(long double)". Everything works with 1.75 and earlier. My code is not using boost::math::isnan directly, so I'm guessing some other included boost component is forward-declaring it or doing something similar? The linking error disappears if I include <boost/math/special_functions/fpclassify.hpp> in a config file that is included by every file in the library. Today I'll try to pinpoint the problem by removing it there and including it before specific boost headers in the source files, but as I said, I'm posting this in case someone already has an idea about the underlying issue. Thanks, Luigi

3 4

Any Interest in a port of ZLib to C++?
by Vinnie Falco 24 Mar '21

24 Mar '21

Beast currently has its own port of ZLib to C++: <https://github.com/boostorg/beast/tree/develop/include/boost/beast/zlib> Is there any interest in having this proposed as its own separate Boost library (with a separate review, which has nothing to do with Beast)? The differences would be as follows: * Ported to use C++11 idioms * Same header-only / compiled source model as Boost.JSON * Better documentation and clear API * Improved tests Programs which use this C++ port of ZLib would get their zlib dependency from Boost instead of the official zlib distribution. And they can integrate it into their projects the same way that Boost libraries are integrated. Or they can include <boost/zlib/src.hpp> in any one translation unit (like JSON). The motivation for this is twofold: * Provide an easier way for users to access ZLib's functionality * To use this in some new libraries that I'm going to propose -- Regards, Vinnie Follow me on GitHub: https://github.com/vinniefalco

11 14

[Boost.JSON] Security Review
by Vinnie Falco 23 Mar '21

23 Mar '21

As part of our commitment to producing the very finest C++ libraries that application developers can trust, the C++ Alliance has commissioned Bishop Fox to perform a security audit of the Boost.JSON library. The report is linked here: <https://cppalliance.org/pdf/C%20Plus%20Plus%20Alliance%20-%20Boost%20JSON%2…> This will report will be published starting in Boost 1.76.0 -- Regards, Vinnie Follow me on GitHub: https://github.com/vinniefalco

1 0

boost library incubator planning shutdown
by Robert Ramey 22 Mar '21

22 Mar '21

I had high hopes for the boost library incubator when I made it. But I think it's pretty clear that those hopes haven't been realized. Maintaining and Enhancing this website required more effort than I had anticipated so it hasn't evolved. I do notice that people do use it from time to time (a couple hundred page hits/day), so it's not totally dead. But it would either have to go forward or be shut down. If someone wanted to take it over that would be fine. But I don't expect anyone to come forward so I'll be shutting it down probably in the next 30 days or so. Robert Ramey

1 0

Mentor application for Boost.Real
by Vikram Chundawat 21 Mar '21

21 Mar '21

Hello everyone, I am Vikram Singh Chundawat, I worked on Boost.Real previous GSoC and I am actively working on the library since. Now, one of the potential mentors Damian Vicino is not mentoring this year, I wish to mentor this project in GSoC 2021 with Laouen Belloli. We have some potential candidates who are working on the library and also some good ideas for the library. The aim last year was to bring Boost.Real to review ready state and some work is still remaining to make it review ready, we found some bugs in the review. Now, we are working on optimizations, bug fixes, and benchmarking. I went through the guidelines of Google and wish to know the procedure for mentor application. Thank You Regards Vikram Singh Chundawat

2 1

Proposing a library to include in Boost
by Mohit Saini 20 Mar '21

20 Mar '21

Hi, This is Mohit Saini. I developed a lazy_map library, whose interface is similar to std::unordered_map but lazy_map is O(1) copiable. Other operations like Deletion, Lookup, Insertion etc. continue to cost O(1).. which also implies that lazy_map is not a simple cow_wrapper<std::unordered_map> .. lazy_map is way more clever than that. Learn more at : https://github.com/tinytrashbin/lazy_map Specially, checkout the section which explains the "Fragment" tree. Lazy_map is heavily used in our codebase for taking snapshot of a very large state ( of size ~ 5 GBs), enabling "fork" of a snapshot in O(1) time for further modification in the forked snapshot, allowing a large number of threads to operate on different snapshots of very large size, concurrently without interfering with each other where each of the thread is even "writing" to their snapshot. I believe such a utility will be very helpful for others too. I'm looking for boost-maintainers who can review and suggest what all I need to do so that lazy_map can be accepted in Boost. Thanks -- Mohit Saini

1 0

Re: [boost] Feedback on GSoC'21 project proposal
by krushnalpatel11＠gmail.com 20 Mar '21

20 Mar '21

I have updated the proposal with the changes you proposed. Please check if all things are updated as per your feedback. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bvno6ifHjo8EdMRuzFqCk9AEB5IgAxf2ag4xdc4… Krushnal http://krushnal.me/ _______________________________________________ Unsubscribe & other changes: http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost </quote> Quoted from: http://boost.2283326.n4.nabble.com/Feedback-on-GSoC-21-project-proposal-tp4… _____________________________________ Sent from http://boost.2283326.n4.nabble.com

1 0

Re: [boost] Boost website changes and .'cxxstd'
by Donovan Dikaio 20 Mar '21

20 Mar '21

I can look into it. But needs to make the requirements clear. So, the task is to show *C++ standard minimum level: C++nn* for Standard attribute for each lib in this page: C++ standard minimum level: C++nn ? And we could replace nn with the actual number by checking the *cxxstd* key in a library's meta info json file. Please let me know if I got it right. On Fri, Dec 25, 2020 at 10:00 AM Louis Tatta <louis(a)cppalliance.org> wrote: > > > ---------- Forwarded message --------- > From: Edward Diener via Boost <boost(a)lists.boost.org> > Date: Wed, Dec 23, 2020 at 7:39 PM > Subject: [boost] Boost website changes and .'cxxstd' > To: <boost(a)lists.boost.org> > CC: Edward Diener <eldiener(a)tropicsoft.com> > > > Even though I have worked a little with PHP in the past I do not have > the talent to make the change to the website which would incorporate the > addition of the meta information json field 'cxxstd' to the Boost > documentation web page for each library. The idea is that if 'cxxstd' is > set to a value the documentation for that library would also show: > > C++ standard minimum level: C++nn > > where nn would be 11, 14, 17, or 20 depending on the value of 'cxxstd'. > Alternatively if there is no 'cxxstd' entry for a library or if the > value of 'cxxstd' is '03', we could either specify 'nn' as '03' or leave > off the line stating the 'C++ standard minimum level completely. > > On the face of it this should be doable in the website code but > evidently Daniel James is the only one who really understands how this > works in the code and he is no longer active in Boost. So if someone > else who understands the website code and PHP could do this it would be > appreciated, since I think it will be valuable telling end-users whether > a Boost library is usable at the C++ compiler level they are using. > > > _______________________________________________ > Unsubscribe & other changes: > http://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost >

8 43

Providing a link to GitHub commit from documentation
by pbristow＠hetp.u-net.com 19 Mar '21

19 Mar '21

I've been considering adding commit hash info to some documentation made using the Quickbook/Boostbook/Docbook/b2/bjam toolchain Using git command line git log or ls-remote I can show the necessary hex digit string: commit 5609fa86e37e1b0eae6466065ba6c8eb3ac0ab2f (HEAD -> refactor1) (It would be useful to have the local commit (rather than remote) so that the generated documentation including this has can be pushed up to remote). Paul@hetpD MINGW64 /i/boost/libs/quan/doc (refactor1) $ git log -n1 HEAD > commit.txt That contains commit 5609fa86e37e1b0eae6466065ba6c8eb3ac0ab2f Author: pabristow <pbristow(a)hetp.u-net.com> Date: Fri Mar 19 15:46:45 2021 +0000 Generated super new version. So this gets this info into a file, but I have yet to see how to get this into the Quickbook or ? during the b2 build. I note that the Boost documentation headers provide this information in the form a link like displayed as d57d645009 with contents https://github.com/boostorg/boost/commit/d57d6450098300343c6fe3a22129791524… but I don't know how this works. Has anyone done anything like this? Suggestions most welcome. Paul

4 4