On Tue, Sep 2, 2025 at 6:10 AM Janko Dedic via Boost <boost@lists.boost.org> wrote:
I would kindly ask the moderators to ban low-effort AI slop such as this from the mailing list. It's an insult to people writing and reading thoughtful reviews.
We are exploring how AI tools may enhance the review process. One idea which emerged is to perform research on the domain and post an information-rich brief to bring reviewers up to speed who are not already subject matter experts. The other idea is to perform research on competing libraries to get a better understanding of what is out there; it is inefficient for N reviewers to each independently repeat the work of analyzing similar offerings to what is being reviewed. I believe these are worthwhile efforts yet there is more work to be done to ensure correct outputs. Perhaps it should have been stated explicitly, that this exploration of applicability of large language models to the reviews is largely an experimental work in progress so I appreciate constructive comments over critiques which carry zero bits of information. Thanks