First of all, I would like to thank everyone who participated in the review process, and Klemens for submitting the library.
In total, we received 9 reviews: 3 ACCEPT, 3 CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT, and 3 REJECT.
The individual reviews are as follows:
Barend Gehrels: ACCEPT [1] Ruben Perez: REJECT [2] Scott Bailey: ACCEPT [3] Mungo Gill: CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT [4] Amlal El Mahrouss: ACCEPT [5] Harold Bott: CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT [6] Darryl Green: CONDITIONALLY ACCEPT [7] Andrzej Krzemienski: REJECT [8] Maximilian Riemensberger: REJECT [9]
After carefully examining all reviews, going through the mailing list discussions, and consulting with Ruben Perez (author of Boost.MySQL) and Klemens, I have decided to REJECT the library due to critical flaws in the API and insufficient documentation. I strongly encourage the author to make another submission after addressing the issues listed below:
Best regards, Mohammad Nejati Review Manager for the proposed Boost.SQLite _______________________________________________
Thank you to: Klemens for your submission, Mohammad for managing the review, and all those that participated. Matt