Re: [Boost-users] Boost Program Options: Any way to have variable number of "objects" each with parameters?

Subject: Re: [Boost-users] Boost Program Options: Any way to have variable number of "objects" each with parameters?
From: Charles Mills (charlesm_at_[hidden])
Date: 2012-06-21 10:16:47

Here is what I have come up with. Any feedback?

 

I first thought of something like this:

 

CircleRadiuses= 4 7 3 .

 

It's okay for objects with only one value (like Circles) but clumsy and
unintuitive for objects with more than one parameter like

 

RectangleHeights= 5 3 7 .

RectangleWidths= 10 4 16 .

 

Although I would like to support "any number" of objects, the reality is
that a likely number is three or four, so restricting it to a maximum of
nine should not be a problem. So here is my plan. Something like

 

[Rectangle1]

Height=5

Width=10

[Rectangle2]

Height=3

Width=4

 

and so forth through Rectangle9. Same sort of deal for Circle1 through 9. (I
think counting from 1 is more user-friendly for people who are not C
programmers.)

 

So, any feedback? Any better way to solve this problem?

 

Charles

From: Charles Mills [mailto:charlesm_at_[hidden]] 
Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2012 6:20 PM
To: 'boost-users_at_[hidden]'
Subject: Boost Program Options: Any way to have variable number of "objects"
each with parameters?

 

I really like the Boost Program Options library. I've used it for one
program now with great effect and I'd like to use it for another, but can't
figure out how to structure what I need to do so that Boost PO could handle
it.

 

I am solely interested in the ".ini file" for this - command line is
irrelevant.

 

The problem is "how does a program allow the specification of a variable
number of 'objects' each of which has parameters of its own?" 

 

Here is a hypothetical program that exemplifies the problem. Suppose a
program were going to create multiple geometric shapes of some sort. An
ideal (unsupported by PO) .ini file might look like

 

rectangles=3

rectangle[0].width=5

rectangle[0].height=10

rectangle[1].width=3

etc.

circles=2

circle[0].diameter=4

etc.

 

Can anyone suggest a way to accomplish this with Boost PO? I'm real flexible
on what the .ini file might look like so long as it solves the problem and
is reasonably explicable to a user. (No need for it to look almost like the
above.)

 

Thanks,

 

Charles