Subject: Re: [geometry] Adapting a model
From: Barend Gehrels (barend_at_[hidden])
Date: 2014-03-25 17:29:42
Adam Wulkiewicz wrote On 25-3-2014 3:42:
> Please don't answer on some email from a different thread if you want
> to create another thread.
> -- Original message --
> I 'm looking to adapt a model for use with Boost.Geometry. To start off,
> I looked to get the intersects algorithm working with two linestrings -
> that fails due to six MPL assertions (unimplemented operation).(note
> that my model's linestring cannot be mutable - it should still be
> possible to use non-mutating algorithms on it?)
> To try to track what's going on, I opted to get it working with the
> example model adaptation instead; that fails to compile too, on line 934
> of get_turn_info.hpp:
> typename strategy::return_type result = strategy::apply(p1, q1);
> And I am afraid I cannot tell what is missing.
> (In short, I copied the example QPoint and QLineString adaptation and
> added a main() calling intersects() - this is what I tried to compile:
> Just one minor correction - changed QPoint::double to double because I
> assume that's the intention)
> Any clues would be appreciated,
> -- End --
> According to this:
> the Linestring should behave like a range of Points.
> I don't know what was the intention that led to the example model
> adaptation but if you replace pointers to QPoint in your example with
> just a QPoint it compiles, almost.
> Almost, because apparently the Point's default ctor is required by
> Box's default ctor.
> Barend is default ctor a part of the Point Concept? Or should we think
> about some other way of default creation of Boxes/Segments/etc.?
No, a point does not need to have a default constructor. It is not part
of the concept. There is already a sort-of-constructing function in the
library and that is boost::geometry::make, returning a point with
For Box/Segments we don't have this yet, so yes, we should think about that.
However, QPoint has a default constructor, so in code of library users
it is fine if that constructor is used. As long as it does not leak into
Geometry list run by mateusz at loskot.net