From: Raja R Harinath (harinath_at_[hidden])
Date: 2000-02-29 01:20:01
> >The standard operating procedure for users of GNU-style tarballs is:
> > 1. Unarchive the tarball and change to the directory.
> > 2. ./configure
> > 3. make
> > 4. make install
> >> Let me try it for Win32 platforms. If that works OK, I will put a
> >> .zip file in the vault, and people can then try to add directories
> >> with scripts for other platforms.
> >Just in case I wasn't clear before, automake needs to invade the source
> >tree. The primary consequence of that the build system's Makefile.in's
> >end up in the source tree, as do the Makefiles. (Though the latter aren't
> >generated until configure time, when the user is preparing to build the
> >I'll wait until I have your zip file and a clear picture of the directory
> >structure therein to comment further. I don't know of any particular
> >strucure that would pose a problem for automake (it's pretty flexible),
> >the only issue is that it needs to invade it.
> Why not insist for Windows on a Cygwin installation? Then we'll have an
> environment, that supports the procedure described above in the same way for
> Windows as for Unix. I've built meanwhile enough Unix tools successfully for
> Windows that were prepared for Cygwin. This would minimize the maintenance
> effort and the boost may just provide a link to Cygwin to get an
> installation of the tools.
One problem with the "config.hpp generated by configure.in" approach
is that the installation is tailored to one compiler -- the compiler
used to configure the package. It usually isn't a problem in the C
world, but it definitely is a problem in the C++ world. Many people
often have multiple, incompatible, C++ compilers. So, for example, if
you configure with Cygwin using GNU C++, you may not be able to use
MSVC on the same install, and vice versa.
You can use --exec-prefix and custom include paths to handle this --
but this requires a whole lot of sophistication, planning, and
maintenance than a simple ./configure; make; make install.
-- Raja R Harinath ------------------------------ harinath_at_[hidden] "When all else fails, read the instructions." -- Cahn's Axiom "Our policy is, when in doubt, do the right thing." -- Roy L Ash
Boost list run by bdawes at acm.org, david.abrahams at rcn.com, gregod at cs.rpi.edu, cpdaniel at pacbell.net, john at johnmaddock.co.uk