Re: [boost] [review][DoubleEnded] Review Results

Subject: Re: [boost] [review][DoubleEnded] Review Results
From: Ion Gaztañaga (igaztanaga_at_[hidden])
Date: 2017-10-27 12:58:44

On 27/10/2017 0:00, Thorsten Ottosen via Boost-users wrote:
> Dear users and members of Boost,
> 
> I'm happy to to announce that Benedek Thaler's Boost.DoubleEnded is 
> /conditionally/ accepted into Boost provided that it can be integrated 
> smoothly with Boost.Container. There are several other conditions, some 
> major and some minor which I will outline below.
> 
> For now, I would like to thank everyone that participated with reviews 
> and comments. We didn't have that many reviews, but the reviewers did 
> spend a lot of time both on review and the following discussions.
> 
> Special thanks also goes to Benedek for his hard work. It is not too 
> often that a GSOC code ends with something of this quality. Two of the 
> world's expert C++ container developers used phrases like "solid"
> and "everything looks clean and beautiful" about the implementation, 
> "tests look very good, corner cases and all", "The reference section is 
> very good". Congratulations, Benedek.

Thanks and congratulations to Benedek! I think devector and batch_deque 
additions will be useful for Boost.Container users. I hope also that the 
integration in Boost.Container and the fruitful discussions that will 
happen in the mailing list will help those reluctant to the inclusion to 
appreciate the new functionality.

Thanks also to all reviewers and specially to Thorsten for his great 
work, patience and help to reach a consensus.

Best,

Ion