Re: [boost] GIL Review

From: Joel de Guzman (joel_at_[hidden])
Date: 2006-10-26 00:12:54

Tom Brinkman wrote:
>>> Thank you! With all due respect to Dr. Reese, I think posting a
>>> review and then asking to be emailed for replies is not right.
>>> The review is a public affair. We would also like to read about
>>> the replies and exchanges that ensue after a reviewer posts his
>>> review. A reviewer should also be responsible to answer and reply
>>> to the questions and answers related to his review _on_list_ in
>>> as much as the one being reviewed (Lubomir et. al.) tries as best
>>> as they can to answer and reply to the reviews. It's not a one
>>> way street.
> 
> Ok, I kinda agree. However, there may have be a reason that they were
> not able to. Not shur why that would be, but in any case I told him
> that he could email me the review if he was unable to post it the
> group himself.  In the future, I'll be firmer and polightly insist
> that they try join the mailing list.

Understood. Thanks!

Regards,
-- 
Joel de Guzman
http://www.boost-consulting.com
http://spirit.sf.net