Boost logo

Boost :

Subject: Re: [boost] [Boost 1.41: list_of] Boost compliation error, > Sun Studio 11 using standard C++ lib
From: Rob Riggs (rob_at_[hidden])
Date: 2010-01-03 15:12:29


On 01/03/2010 11:45 AM, shing fan wrote:
> So, with limited resources (time, labour, and technical expertise on complier), would it be safe to assume that i should pursue other routes (e.g. boost with gcc or with stlport) and not continue with the beast (compling boost with libCstd?). Your professional opinion is much appreciated.
>

C++ on Solaris is a bit of a lost cause at the moment. The near-term
route that we have decided to take is to abandon Sun Studio altogether
and focus on porting to GCC on Solaris using the GCC package from
Blastwave. I encourage others to consider doing the same.

The issue that you will run into with both Sun Studio & stlport and with
GCC is that neither has working locale support on Solaris. This is not
an immediate issue for us so it was a reasonable compromise. My
understanding is that locale support should be working in the near
future with "regular" GCC on Solaris using the
--enable-clocale=ieee_1003.1-2001 option.

Longer term, we do not think Sun Studio is a viable platform for C++
development. In the near future Sun will have to support Sun Studio
with 3 C++ standard libraries as they have stated publicly that they
will be adding Apache's libstdcxx (but not when). This is an untenable
position for third-party library developers (whether open or
proprietary). None of the three libraries are binary compatible, so
every third-party library one uses must be compiled with the same
library. Additionally, Sun will either have to wait to include the
Apache libstdcxx until c++1x is ratified and their compiler & library
supports all its features or it will have to support a 4th C++ standard
library. However, given Sun's history with C++ support, the option they
are most likely to choose is to have a broken C++ implementation that
doesn't support all of c++1x for the next decade.

GCCfss from Sun is another alternative, but it appears to be at a
crossroads with GCC's recent license change. Sun can no longer modify
GCC to produce IL code for their compiler back-end without also
releasing those tools under the GPL. Last I checked, this did have
working locale support. This is really the only working C++
implementation on Solaris at this point. But its lifespan appears to be
rather limited.

Rob


Boost list run by bdawes at acm.org, gregod at cs.rpi.edu, cpdaniel at pacbell.net, john at johnmaddock.co.uk